"Fullmetal Alchemist: Valley of the White Petals" (2006) by Makoto Inoue REVIEW

As a fan of the Fullmetal Alchemist franchise, I was willing to dive deeper in Ed and Al's universe. My younger brother (who, coincidentally, is taller than me) found this book in the library and a was nice enough to check it out for me!

From I could gather, this light novel takes place within the three year gap before the series begins. Colonel Roy Mustang sends Ed to a town in the middle of nowhere called Wisteria to check things out and fill out a report. When the Elrics get there, they meet a girl named Ruby that helps them into the town. According to rumors, Wisteria is a paradise for those who have no home to go to, those who felt were treated poorly by the military or the outside world. In Wisteria, Ed and Al discover that the economy of the town runs on equivalent exchange, just like alchemy, and everyone seems to love living and working there. However, dark secrets lurk in this paradise and soon reveal themselves, leaving the brothers to wonder if this town is really a place to call home.

This novel is a great addition to the franchise, but, unfortunately, it falls flat in some areas. This is a story of teamwork and fairness and the author teaches these morals well. The characters are exactly how they are in the manga and the anime, making it a true tie-in. However, the main plot itself gave me strong deja vu of the Liore story early in the comics and the shows. Also, the ending felt really rushed. There were characters that hated each other and didn't want anything to do with one another, but, right after an argument, they suddenly drop the ball and become nice people to everyone, leaving me to feel robbed of a chance to experience some great character development.

Even with its faults including some mistranslatiosn, though, this is still an enjoyable read for Fullmetal Alchemist fans. Would I recommend it to people not familiar with the franchise? Not so much.

3/5 Stars

Comments

"Need for Speed" (2014) REVIEW

I know I'm not the only one who thought this movie was going to be a flop. I mean, not only is it a high-speed street racing movie, but it's also a videogame movie. Still, I gave it a shot, but mostly for the D-Box experience. Even with the earnings from winning illegal street races, Tobey Marshall (Aaron Paul) is still unable to keep his auto repair shop from his father open. For a chance to get $500,000, Tobey takes an offer from his street racing rival and successful car dealer Dino Brewster (Domonic Cooper) to finish building the Ford Mustang that Caroll Shelby was working on when he died. After building the car and selling it without Dino's consent, Dino challenges Tobey and Tobey's friend, Pete, to a street race for the money. Nearing the end of the race, desperate for revenge, Dino pushes Pete over a bridge and drives away, leaving Tobey to be blamed for vehicular manslaughter. Two years later, fresh out of prison, Tobey seeks out to knock Dino off his p...

What to Read After Insomiac's Spider-Man

So you've just defeated the Sinister Six, maybe done a side mission here and there, or perhaps 100% completed what most are considering the best Spider-Man game ever made (and they're right). What now? Where do you go from here to learn more about the wisecracking wall-crawler? Besides Tom Holland's performance in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, we've never really seen Spider-Man portrayed so solidly like we have here. This, my friends, is where the fun part comes in: Entering the vast world of Spider-Man presented in comics and novels. Allow me to be your guide, providing recommendations for any requests you may be wishing for. "I just want more..." Well, you're in luck because Marvel has 2 options for you! Spider-Man: Hostile Takeover is the official prequel novel to the game, taking place 6 months prior. It follows Spider-Man trying to find an imposter killing people, working with a newfound friend from the police force to take ...

Blue Beetle Rebirth Vol. 1: The More Things Change (Rebirth #1, #1-#6)

2/5 Jaime Reyes as the Blue Beetle has interested me and been on my reading list for a while. When I first discovered the character watching Batman: The Brave and the Bold , seeing Jaime as a relatable teen arguing with the sentient suit that gives him his powers, his New 52 line had already been cancelled. Then Geoff Johns wrote Rebirth and added a little scene with Jaime Reyes that I thought was both very interesting and promising. In short, Keith Giffen doesn't deliver in this volume until issue #6, where he kind of gives a small splice of what the series could be. Getting the obvious out of the way, the dialogue here is absolutely horrible. I tell myself it feels like a first draft, but then there are moments of repetition and sentences upon sentences of nothing going on. By then, it feels more like a very bloated outline with the characters speaking mostly hot air. The dialogue here isn't flat, it's completely empty. This, in turn, makes all the charac...

Kevin Lau

Search This Blog